Retail Traders Turn Bearish on SPY Amid $25.8 Trillion Debt Refinancing Concerns

AMZN +0.23%

Quick Read

• The SPDR S&P 500 ETF (SPY) saw its social sentiment score drop 39% in one week to 35 out of 100.

• SPY fell 0.8% on Monday amid concerns over $25.8T in U.S. debt maturing between 2026 and 2028.

• Interest payments reached $970B in 2025 and now exceed the entire defense budget.

• Some investors get rich while others struggle because they never learned there are two completely different strategies to building wealth. Don’t make the same mistake, learn about both here.

Shares of the SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust (NYSE: SPY) fell 0.8% on Monday, coinciding with a sharp deterioration in retail investor sentiment. SPY's social sentiment score dropped to 35 out of 100 earlier today, down from a neutral 57.3 just last week. That's a 39% collapse in sentiment in under seven days. Discussions on Reddit show growing pessimism about equity valuations, debt concerns, and a rotation into defensive assets like gold. Meanwhile, speculative options activity remains elevated, a classic warning sign before corrections.

Defensive Rotation and Debt Wall Fears

Reddit's investing communities are increasingly bearish. A detailed post on r/stocks arguing gold has "the strongest bull case in modern history" gained 691 upvotes and sparked 280 comments. The author laid out a comprehensive bear case centered on the 2026-2028 debt refinancing crisis, noting that $25.8 trillion in U.S. debt matures over those three years. The post warned: "We're not in an AI bubble, we're in an everything bubble. It is not normal for gold, bitcoin, and the S&P to all be at ATH." Central banks are buying gold at rates not seen in decades, a signal that sophisticated investors are hedging against currency debasement.

Gold may have the strongest bull case in modern history by u/13jfncjai31 in stocks

And there are real reasons to be concerned:

• SPY sentiment (35) now trails major holdings like Alphabet (NASDAQ:GOOGL) (69.1) and Amazon (NASDAQ:AMZN) (63.2) by wide margins

• $25.8 trillion in U.S. debt matures 2026-2028, forcing refinancing at higher rates

• Interest payments hit $970 billion in 2025, exceeding the entire defense budget

Speculative Excess Meets Technical Weakness

SPY's 14-day RSI sits at 59.1, recovering from oversold territory (35.4 on November 20) but failing to regain bullish momentum above 60. The fund bounced 4.7% from its November 20 low of $652.53 but remains below its October peak of $689.70. Polymarket prediction markets show 50/50 odds on whether Bitcoin outperforms SPY in December, reflecting zero conviction either way. Watch for continued defensive rotation and whether SPY can reclaim $690, or if the sentiment collapse accelerates into year-end tax-loss selling.

Why Some Investors Get Rich While Others Struggle

The fact is there are two totally different investment paths you can take right now. And while either can make you some money, choosing the right one at the right time can mean the difference between just getting by and getting truly rich. Most people don’t even realize the difference, and that mistake can be devastating for your portfolio. Whether you’re investing $1,000, or $1,000,000 today, learn the difference and put yourself on the right path. See the report.